Diversity Management Change Projects: In Need of Alternative Conceptual Approaches?
AbstractDrawing on a meta-analysis of an evaluation of a European Social Fund project aimed at enhancing employment opportunities for women in Information Technology, Electronic and Computing (ITEC), this paper critically debates how effectual a diversity management approach alone is as an underpinning rationale for change in the complex area of diversity. The paper draws on the experiences of ‘partner organizations’, gathered through interviews conducted during the evaluation stage of the project. The paper discusses some of the tensions experienced by partner organizations, thus providing new insights into why such projects are not as effectual as they might be. The paper concludes by presenting a case for the need to re-conceptualise how change as part of a wider diversity management approach might best be conceptualized. We suggest that a ‘systems approach’ could prove a more fruitful way of conceptualizing change of this nature given the inter-dependences between different organizations and institutions.
ABIR-AM, P.G. (2010) Gender and Technoscience: A Historical Perspective. Journal of Technology Management & Innovation, 5(1), 153-165.
ASHLEY, L. (2010) Making a difference? The use (and abuse) of diversity management in the UK’s elite law firms. Work, Employment and Society, 24(4), 711-727.
AVDELIDU-FISCHER, N. (2011) The labour market context and its effect on women’s participation in independent business and professional networks. In: G. Healy, G. Kirton, and M. Noon (2011) Equality, Inequalities and Diversity. Contemporary Challenges and Strategies. Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire:
BASSETT-JONES, N., Brown, R.B. and Cornelius, N. (2007) Delivering Effective Diversity Management Through Effective Structures. Systems Research and Behavioural Science Syst Res. 24, 59-67.
BIEDENBACH,T. and Söderholm,A. (2008) The Challenge of Organizing Change in Hypercompetitive Industries: A Literature Review. Journal of Change Management, 8(2), 123-145.
BLEIJENBERGH, I., Peters, P. and Poutsma, E. (2010) Diversity management beyond the business case. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion, 29(5), 436-457.
BRINER, R.B. and Rousseau, D.M. (2011) Evidence-Based I-O Psychology: Not There Yet. Industrial and Organizational Psychology, 4(1) March, 2-22.
CAO, G., Clarke, S. and Lehaney, B. (2003) Diversity Management in Organizational Change: Towards a Systemic Framework. Systems Research and Behavioural Science, Sys. Res.
CAVANA, R.Y., D.M. Boyd, and RJ. Taylor (2007) A Systems Thinking Study of Retention and Recruitment Issues for the New Zealand Army Electronic Technical Trade Group. Systems Research and Behavioural Science. Syst. Res. 24, 201-216.
COCKBURN, C. (2001) Equal opportunities: the short and long agenda. Industrial Relations Journal, 20(3), 213-223.
DASS, P. and Parker, B. (1999) Strategies for managing human resource diversity: From resistance to learning. Academy of Management, 13(2), 68-80.
DICK, P. and Nadin, S. (2006) Reproducing gender inequalities? A critique of realist assumptions underpinning personnel selection research and practice. Journal of Occupational and Organizational Psychology (2006) 79, 481-498.
DICKENS, L. (1999) Beyond the business case: a three-pronged approach to equality action. Human Resource Man- agement Journal, 9(1), 9-19.
DTI (2005) Women in the IT Industry. Towards a Business Case for Diversity. DTI, London.
ECWT (2011) Position Paper on Gender and Technologies: Lining up a Gender Action-Plan for the Digital Agenda (eGEN – ADA 2011-2015). http://www.asszisztencia.hu/ntit/ down/Position_Paper_ECWT.pdf [Accessed June 2, 2011]
E-SKILLS (2011) Technology Insights 2011: Summary report. http://www.e-skills.com/technologyinsights2011. [Accessed February 14, 2011]
EUREOPEAN COMMISSION (2004) Widening Women’s Work in Information and Communication Technology, Fon- dation Travail-Universite ASBL. http://www.ftu-namur.org [Accessed June 2, 2011]
EVANS, C. (2012) Recruitment initiatives aimed at increasing the gender diversity within ITEC employment: not so ‘gender neutral’. Equality, Diversity and Inclusion: An International Journal (forthcoming, currently available via Earlycite).
FAGEN, C., Rubery, J., Grimshaw, D., Smith, M., Hebson, G. and Figueiredo (2005) Gender Mainstreaming in the enlarged European Union: recent developments in the European employment strategy and Social Inclusion Process. Industrial Relations Journal, 36(6), 568-591.
FOSTER, C. and Harris, L. (2005) ‘Easy to say, Difficult to Do: Diversity Management in Retail’, Human Resource Management Journal, 15(3), 4-17.
Glover, J. and Kirton, G. (2006) Women, Employment and Organizations. Routledge, Oxon.
Glover, J. and Guerrier, Y. (2010) Women in Hybrid Roles in IT Employment: A return to ‘Nimble Fingers’? Journal of Technology Management & Innovation, 5(1), 86-94.
GREENE, A.M. and Kirton, G. (2009) Diversity Management in the UK. Routledge. London, Routledge.
GRIFFITHS, M. and Moore, K. (2010) ‘Disappearing Women’: A Study of Women Who Left the UK ICT Sector. Journal of Technology Management & Innovation, 5(1), 96-107.
GRIFFITHS, M. and Moore, K. (2006) The Women in ICT (WINICT) Final Report. University of Salford.
HANNAH, S.T., Lord, R. G. and Pearce, C. L. (2011) Leader- ship and collective requisite complexity. Organizational Psychology Review, 1(3), 215-238.
HEALY, G., Kirton, G. and Noon, M. (2011) Equality, Inequalities and Diversity. Contemporary Challenges and Strategies. Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire.
HERRING, C. (2009) Does Diversity Pay?: Race, Gender and the Business Case for Diversity. American Sociological Review, 2009, 74 April, 208-224.
JACKSON, M. C. (2010) ‘Reflections on the Development and Contribution of Critical Systems Thinking and Practice’, Systems Research and Behavioural Science. Syst. Res., 27, 133-139.
JAYNE, M. E. A. and Dipboye, R.L. (2004) Leveraging Diversity to Improve Business Performance: Research Findings and Recommendations for Organizations. Human Resource Management,Winter 2004, 43(4), 409-424.
JOHNSTON, W. and Packer, A. (1987) Workforce 2000: Work and Workers for the 21st Century.The Hudson Institute, New York.
KALEV, A., Dobbin, F. and Kelly, E. (2006) Best Practices or best Guesses? Assessing the Efficacy of Corporate Affirmative Action and Diversity Policies. American Sociological Review, 2006, 71 August, 589-617.
KATZ, D. and Kahn, R.L. (1969) Common Characteristics of Open Systems. In, F. E. Emery (1969) (Eds) Systems Thinking. Penguin Books, Middlesex.
KERSTEN, A. (2000) Diversity management. Dialogue, dialectics and diversion. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 13(3), 235-248.
KOCHAN, T., Bezrukova, K., Ely, R., Jackson, S. Joshi, A., Jehn, K., Leonard, J., Levine, D. And Thomas D. (2003) The Effects of Diversity on Business Performance: Report on the Diversity Research Network. Human Resource Management, Spring 2003, 42(1), 3-21.
LANVIN, B. and Passman, P.S. (2008) Building E-skills for the Information Age.The Global Information technology Report 2007-2008.World Economic Forum.
MARVIN, S. and Girling, G. (2000) What is managing diversity and why does it matter? Human Resource Development International, 3(4), 419-433.
NATIONAL ACADEMY of ENGINEERING (2002) Diversity in Engineering. Managing the Workforce of the Future. National Academy Press,Washington.
NG, E. S. W. (2008) Why Organizations Choose to Manage Diversity? Toward a Leadership-Based Theoretical Framework. Human Resource Development Review, 7(1) March, 58-78.
NG, E.S. W. and Burke, R.J. (2005) ‘Person-OrganizationFit and the War for Talnet. Does Diversity Management Make a difference? International Journal of HRM, 16(7),1195-1210.
ÖZBILGIN, M. F., Beauregard, T.A., Tatli, A. and Bell, M.P. (2011) Work-Life, Diversity and Intersectionality: A Critical Review and Research Agenda. International Journal of Management Review, 13, 177-198.
OSWICK, C. (2011) The social construction of diversity, equality and inclusion. In: Healy, G., Kirton, G. and Noon, M. (2011) Equality, Inequalities and Diversity. Contemporary Challenges and Strategies. Palgrave Macmillan, Hampshire.
ROYAL ACADEMY of ENGINEERING (2007) Equalitec Diversity Forum. Diversity: Changing Corporate Cultures. Summary Report.
SHEN, J., Chanda, A., D’Netto, B. and Monga, M. (2009) Managing diversity through human resource management: an international perspective and conceptual framework.The International Journal of Human Resource Management, 20(2) February, 235-251.
SYMONS, M. and Rowlands, K.N. (2011) Diversity and its Impact on Organizational Performance: The Influence of Diversity Constructions on Expectations and Outcomes. Journal of Technology Management & Innovation, 6(3), 172-183.
TATLI, A. and Özbilgin, M. F. (2009) Understanding Diversity Managers’ Role in Organizational Change: Towards a Conceptual Framework. Canadian Journal of Administrative Sciences. DOI: 10.1002/CJAS.107.
VALENDUC, G. (2011) Not a job for life? Women’s progression, conversion, and dropout in ICT professions. International Journal of Gender, Science and Technology, 3(2), 460-482.
WENTLING, R. M. (2004) Factors that assist and barriers that hinder success of diversity initiatives in multinational corporations. Human Resource Development International, 7(2), 165-180.
WHITE, L. (2000) Changing the “whole system” in the public sector. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 13(2),162-177.
YOUNG, M. (2009) A meta model of change. Journal of Organizational Change Management, 22(2), 524-548.
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).